Whole new engineers are more than left brains on a stick. Engineers have creative right brains, executive forebrains, emotional brains, and they show up ready in the world embodied in flesh and blood. See Jorge Cham’s brilliant comic below or go to phdcomics by clicking here or on the comic:
Engineering education misleads young engineers about what engineering practice is all about. By concentrating almost all classroom air time on mathematics and the solution of well-formed problem s in physics or engineering science, we give young people the impression that they will spend most of their time doing these things at work in there real world.
Yet careful reflection about what engineers actually do during a day reveals that they engage in a variety of acts involving natural language. Engineers write reports, emails, prepare and give presentations, speak on the phone, in the hallway. Only occasionally do engineers do math, solve problems, and the other things that most of their training concentrated on.
As a result, there is a need following the usual cold war engineering education to backfill a young engineer’s education in the area of communication, but even these well-intended efforts concentrate on macro matters of form and ignore micro-level concerns for the nuts and bolts of language. Fortunately, the discipline of philosophy discusses these matters under the rubric of speech acts, and modern coaching practice has made speech acts a core competency.
A good place to read about these matters is in the book Language and the Pursuit of Happiness
by Chalmers Brothers, especially chapter 7. Master coach, Lloyd Raines has a lovely handout on speech acts (here) and the wheel of complete communication, illustrated by a number of practical examples.
A small step toward a more practice relevant education would be to incorporate these ideas into engineering education and the pedagogical training of engineering professors and instructors. ThreeJoy offers a number of training courses for students and for faculty in which speech acts play a crucial role. Contact me at deg@threejoy.com to learn more.